Could Peer-to-Peer Help Independent Businesses? 8
AmericanInKiev asks: "As an antidote to the trend of big businesses wiping out the independant business/cafe/bookshops - is it possible to use P2P applications to link related independant businesses rather than watch them die one by one? For example, you go to a small bookshop and ask for "The long dark tea-time of the soul" by Douglas Adams. "Fresh out" they say, but a quick P2P lookup shows the book available around the corner. A friend of mine runs a fourth generation retail nursery, but the Big Box stores buy in bulk and often sell plants as loss leaders. If he had a P2P system which could coordinate inventories across multiple small nurseries, they could buy in bulk, and search each others inventories, and aggregate shared stock to fill large orders from tight inventories. In a fashion, P2P and a common courier system, would create a kind of power grid effect for small businesses allowing load sharing, individual contribution, and economy of scale. Is there a P2P technology currently oriented towards this market?"
Probably not (Score:3)
If you are a little guy who wants to go up agenst the Walmarts and the B&N's of the world you better have something specific to draw people into your shop. I don't think P2p inventory is going to do it.
Car Parts (Score:1)
Re:Be your own boss, make keys (Score:2)
Another thing to be wary of:
Customer: Do you have a flowering chestnut tree?
Shopkeep: No, but it seems that the guy in the next street/town/etc. has one. You could go over there and get it.
Customer: Jeez, I'll just go to the mega store and save myself the running around.
Many mom-and-pop shops have died by trying to go toe-to-toe with the biggies. Find out what you provide that they don't (service, service, service) and make sure that customers and POTENTIAL customers know about that.
Avoid the buzzwords, and answer the real questions.
The problem is completely different. (Score:2)
Its a whole big mess of software, policies, procedures, and politics. You'd accomplish more by trying to start a new Fidonet relay in your region.
Those problems aside, though, I'd love to see something like that work. Looks like a tough sell, but maybe there are a few niche industries it can be done in?
"It's been done" and "It's not a SMOP" (Score:2)
As a concept, this has been floating around for years, even in technological form (and decades, even centuries, in purely people forms). Read Negroponte from five years back - his favorite example was lots of people getting together to buy cars in bulk.
Now, be that as it may, this isn't a case of a "small matter of programming." It's a classic political Prisoner's Dilemma. If I tell the customer here in my store "Go get it elsewhere," how can I be sure that "elsewhere" will do the same thing in return? Capitalism rewards treachery. Treachery is most often a short term game, and capitalism makes it extremely easy to favor the short-term and screw the long term. Peer-to-peer doesn't do anything to remove a retailer's unease about sending a customer to another store. They'd sooner try to keep the customer by placing an order for the customer right then and there (and pretty much any media store (book, record, video, etc) will do that).
-----
Libraries use a similar system (Score:1)
Some links to systems set up like this (there's others, these are just the ones I know about):
Longview Public Library [longview.wa.us] is linked with the Lower Columbia College library
Oregon State University Valley Library [orst.edu]; via Telnet [orst.edu]
Oregon Union List of Serials [state.or.us]
Re:Probably not (Score:2)
Be your own boss, make keys (Score:1)
I don't think software is the issue, something like that would be really easy to set up using database stuff that's out there now that might not look beautiful, but it would do the trick. My concerns are mostly commerce related, first off, there needs to be some way to sort out the scum of the business world, affiliates just wanting in on everybody else's work, which implies a cost involved (as with anything), and who's to decide a registration fee that won't lead everyone into practically being part of a big business?
Outside of that, it sounds like a really easy thing to do, it's just a matter of getting businesses to want to go in together on it, promotion, etc. Call it your own, do it yourself, make the world a better place, like most ideas it just sounds like a lot of setup.