Searching for a Realistic MPEG-4 Solution? 40
gmezero asks: "Over the last year I have been listening to the trumpet of MPEG-4 being sounded, and I am eager to take up the charge and implement it within my company for our corporate communications. In the past we have used MPEG-1 because to it's commonality. However, due primarily to size limitations (among many other issues that have evolved over the last year), I am getting pressure to move us to WMV for it's perceived 'compatibility' as all of our staff have Media Player on their systems. Unfortunately, nobody seems to realize the fact that WMVs may be Media Player version dependent as well and lock us into future upgrade issues. I can not demand for our GIS group to roll out a stand alone player (eg: DIVX), and I am getting down to a deadline of next week to finalize this platform selection. My pitch to sell MPEG-4 within my company boils down to one major issue, and that brings me to my question. How do I create a MPEG-4 file that will be player independent, short of the player pulling down a new codec for their existing installed media player (QT, WMP, Real)?"
OGM maybe (Score:1, Interesting)
QT.. (Score:4, Interesting)
Mission Impossible (Score:2, Interesting)
I would avoid wmv, rm and mov like the plague. They are all properitary container formats. For a container format use you are probably stuck with avi. It is supported by most players. It's main problem is that it is becoming somewhat outdated, which can cause problem with modern codecs.
If you actually had some possibility to install something I would have recommended Videolan. A single stand-alone platform independant player that doesn't use external codecs but instead includes its own. A player like that should be easy to support and cause minimum codec problems. An avi or mkv container with an mpeg-4 codec (xvid, divx, etc.) and aac or mp3 for sound should work perfectly in Videolan and you wouldn't have to worry about having trouble playing it in the future.
Ok, time to quite dreaming. The video codec market is a patent minefield so it practically impossible for a commercial entity to use open source video tools in USA. Good look with wmv
Re:It all depends on the codecs available (Score:3, Interesting)
Thanks!