
AU Regulations on LAN Cabling? 146
An anonymous reader asks: "After getting a ridiculous quote for the cost of rewiring an office, I started investigating the possibility of doing all the phone/data cabling myself. About 40 RJ-45 ports all coming back to a central patch panel that would be patched into the phone or data switch as needed. My research found that doing this simple job would be illegal in Australia, according to the Australian Communications Authority's (ACA) website. According to them, they have the right to walk in at any time and demand an audit of your LAN, and if it was not installed by a registered cabler, you can be fined up to $13,000. My question is, how does this compare to legislation in other parts of the world? Also, has anyone in Australia ever been subject to one of these 'cabling audits'? Was it painful?"
Sounds like Pro-Union Legislation (Score:5, Insightful)
Re:Sounds like Pro-Union Legislation (Score:5, Insightful)
though, is it just for permanent installations? make yours 'non-permanent'... in other words, just leave the cables on the floor in one big mess.
and see how easy it would be to register yourself as a cabler..
Re:Sounds like Pro-Union Legislation (Score:3, Insightful)
ding ding ding
Or...
Go wireless
Or...
Find a cable installer that works in a large company and pay your new buddy a reasonable sum to do the job off company time. You should be able to pay considerably better than his wage while paying considerably less than what the company would charge you.
Re:Sounds like Pro-Union Legislation (Score:2)
Re:Sounds like Pro-Union Legislation (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:Sounds like Pro-Union Legislation (Score:4, Insightful)
This is a perfect example of why groups of people should not be allowed to exert political influence, and how unions can turn bad (since, in their basic form (group bargaining for employment benefits), a union is a great thing).
I'd be more broad minded in my criticism.
Yes, unions can act badly, creating this obvious market inefficiency due to their aggregated power in the labor-selling marketplace.
But, just as concentrated power in the labor market can be bad, there are at least as many if not more examples of where market dominance by corporations cause inherent inefficiencies in the free market system.
The most efficient system is where there aer large numbers of buyers and sellers of labor (or anything else). As the number of either decreases, then one or the other side are in a position to take advantage of the market for their own gain, be they unions or employers.
In my world, the intersecting set of employees and stockholders would be much larger than it is today.
Re:Sounds like Pro-Union Legislation (Score:3, Interesting)
Re:Sounds like Pro-Union Legislation (Score:2)
You haven't a clue what you are talking about. I DO have an Electrical Engineering Degree, but I would still defer to the time-served electrician any day of the week on most things. An Engineering Degree teaches you lots of theory, but very little practice in general.
Re:Sounds like Pro-Union Legislation (Score:2)
Gee thanks. I think I do. Please post proof that I am wrong. Just because your EE program was all theory and nothing practical does not mean that ALL EE programs are that way. There is nothing an electrician does or knows that can't be taught in a 1 year vo-tech program.
Re:Sounds like Pro-Union Legislation (Score:2)
Re: (Score:3, Interesting)
Why wire line phones are only popular in USA (Score:2)
Re:Why wire line phones are only popular in USA (Score:2)
That speed was really the only thing that kept Ma Bell from being split up long before it did. For decades, it was illegal to connect any non-AT&T equipment to the phone network because it could potentially "damage" the phone infrastructure. There are probably few here (and I'm not one of them) who remember that it was at one time nearly impossible to buy telephones, that
Re:Why wire line phones are only popular in USA (Score:2)
"oh, I just dropped the phone" (Score:2)
The other day I knocked it off the table. Not a scratch on the phone, but one of the prongs of the receiver cradle punched a hole in the TV remote!
Re:Sounds like Pro-Union Legislation (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Re:Sounds like Pro-Union Legislation (Score:2)
Many years ago at an organization I will not name research staff were not supposed to run network cable because the union rules required that members of a particular union run all cable, even the cable in cable trays in the corridors. If you followed the rules, it would take a couple months for them to get to it and they'd screw it up. In order to get anything done, the research staff would organize fast, precisely timed "guerilla cable laying parties" between union shifts. In this case, the union rules ju
RTFA (Score:5, Informative)
On the front page it has a link to a pdf listing results from the 2004 inspections / audits. I think it was something like 600 inspections and 400 audits.
The site has gone down now and I closed acrobat reader so I can't find the exact info.
Re:RTFA (Score:2)
Who paid them off? (Score:3, Insightful)
Or gain the licensing yourself and start doing some side work.
Damien
Lemme put on my Union Hat. (Score:5, Insightful)
*screws on hat tightly, to cut off circulation to brain*
"Union Cable Layers would have been trained as apprentices in this kind of work, and received whatever other training was necessary for local building codes, etc...
Your average Joe would do a slipshod job and your cabling would be sub-standard and not work as well. In addition, an untrained cable-monkey might lay cables in places that were dangerous to the rest of the building structures (across high voltage, etc..) and possibly causing disaster and lawsuits. You wouldn't want that, would you?
And if you even think of doing this yourself, expect to get a visit from the brotherhood of Electricians, Cable Layers and Egg Candlers Local 547."
Ahem.
Re:Lemme put on my Union Hat. (Score:1)
Re:Lemme put on my Union Hat. (Score:2, Funny)
Re:Lemme put on my Union Hat. (Score:3, Informative)
There was a time when this was a necessary position, as most people are loathe to break open an egg for their cake batter and pour in an embryo.
Re:Who paid them off? (Score:2)
FTFA:
Phones not working properly... Oh, the
Re:Who paid them off? (Score:3, Insightful)
Do you have a clue as to why building & electric codes are necessary?
Re:Who paid them off? (Score:2)
It's quite simple. Protectionism by the unions.
Re:Who paid them off? (Score:2)
The difference is that you don't own the property.
If the homeowner does their own electrical work, and they screw up, the worst they can do is burn down their own property.
When you apply for a permit for your own property, you sign a waiver saying that you're capable of doing the work, and that you hold them harmless if you're a bumbling idiot who runs 220v through 26gauge wire.
If you
Re:Who paid them off? (Score:2)
But then what if they sell it? How would the new owner know that un-inspected work was done?
Re:Who paid them off? (Score:2)
But then what if they sell it? How would the new owner know that un-inspected work was done?
:o)
Uhh.. maybe because when they go to look at it, instead of a house, they see a smoking crater?
Seriously though, where did I say that there is no inspection done? You get a permit (required by law to do work on the electrical) an inspector comes to see that the work is done properly. Even
Re:Who paid them off? (Score:2)
an inspector comes to see that the work is done properly.
But wouldn't the inspector see if you screwed things up?
Re:Who paid them off? (Score:2)
But wouldn't the inspector see if you screwed things up?
Yes, that's why I said that.
The problem is that the inspector doesn't come to supervise. You get a permit (which is good for 6 months or so), and do the work. When you're done, you call the inspector to see that it's done properly.
What happens if the house burns down between the time you start the work and the inspector comes?
Re:Who paid them off? (Score:2)
The way this works in the real world is that people basically say "fuck the law" and do it anyway, and
Re:Who paid them off? (Score:2)
Which is what I said.
Ownership has nothing to do with it
Wrong. Ownership has everything to do with it. If you own the property, you're allowed to do the work without being a certified electrician.
That suit would be thrown out on the grounds that my parents KNEW that they were hiring an unlicensed electrician.
Yeah, just like the SCO suit was thrown out for lack of evidence, and the McDonald's suit was thrown out because the granny opened
Re:Who paid them off? (Score:2)
WTF? No shit sherlock, that's what this is all about... I'm not talking about what the current (broken and paid for by union lobbyists) law is saying, I am talking about what the law SHOULD be. Ownership has NOTHING TO DO with the quality and correctness of the work, and THAT is indisputable.
As for comparing this with SCO or McDonaldl, well, SCO is a completely diffe
Re:Who paid them off? (Score:2)
all to protect unions
Sorry, but *what*?!?!?
Please explain how people breaking the law (by not getting permits and inspections) protects unions. I think your logic is pretty twisted.
As I said, (in most jurisdictions) you can get a permit to work on your own house without being a certified electrician.
if you have a tiny bit of common sense and can obey basic principles, there is absolutely no reason you
Re:Who paid them off? (Score:2)
Re:Who paid them off? (Score:2)
Re:Who paid them off? (Score:2)
If it's your house, and you're living in it, I understand your logic. But if you're renting an office or home, and discover a problem with the wiring (such as it being 50 years old and had polarity reversed on random power points) at least if there is a legal standard you can pressure the landlord to fix it. I worked in an office that was like that, the fuseboxes were ob
Re:Who paid them off? (Score:2)
Re:Who paid them off? (Score:2)
That's a distortion of the truth.
Repairs or upgrades (homeowners or handymen repairing a sink, replacing a toilet, etc), don't need a licensed plumber.
You only really need a licensed plumber for projects for which require a building permit, and thus a county/city building inspector to sign off on the work.
Even that's bad... (Score:2)
Where I live (Alberta), a homeowner can do their own electrical/plubming work, even for jobs that require a permit. You only have to have be licensed if you're doing work on someone else's property. The job still requires an inspector to sign off on it.
If you screw up between the time of getting the permit and having it inspected, about the worst yo
Re:Who paid them off? (Score:2)
Pay off your lawmakers (Score:5, Informative)
It happens all over. In California, IIRC, we still can't install plastic water supply lines in houses because they are "unsafe". Funny, though, that they seem to be safe in lots of other states. I'm quite sure that the donations from the plumbing contractors and pipefitters' unions doesn't come into play at all.
Our yacht club can't buy booze at Costco because the regulations require us to buy from a "distributor", not a manufacturer or retailor. At a informational meeting for club officers the ABC (alcoholic beverage control) spokesman was pestered with the question "why can't we just go to Costco?" and his rather amusing and refreshingly honest answer was, "because you didn't pay your lawmakers as much as the distribution cartel did."
Re:Pay off your lawmakers (Score:5, Funny)
And you call yourselves a yacht club?!? Get some more millionaires in there!
Re:Pay off your lawmakers (Score:1, Flamebait)
Seriously, I think your point would have more impact if you used a slightly different example. As it is, I had to fight the urge to cheer for that distribution cartel you're complaining about.
Re: (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:Pay off your lawmakers (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Re:Pay off your lawmakers (Score:2)
Any kid with a possession that cost several thousand dollars is clearly a rich kid. Let alone a possession that is entirely a luxurery item. Although renting could offer a slightly more reasonable option.
"Also the bigger boats need a lot of crew, so many of the members have no boat at all."
Do they really give the help... err crew, membership?
Totally off main topic but my Karma can take a hit (Score:2)
Re:Totally off main topic but my Karma can take a (Score:2)
Re:Pay off your lawmakers (Score:2)
Our yacht club can't buy booze at Costco because the regulations require us to buy from a "distributor", not a manufacturer or retailor. At a informational meeting for club officers the ABC (alcoholic beverage control) spokesman was pestered with the question "why can't we just go to Costco?" and his rather amusing and refreshingly honest answer was, "because you didn't pay your lawmakers as much as the distribution cartel did."
"The land of the free"
Alex
AU governments site down (Score:4, Funny)
One Word (Score:5, Insightful)
Re:One Word (Score:2)
Wireless would never work for a lot of people in my office. We have to transfer too many large files back and forth from the servers. Some of us are hurting on a 100mbit switched network and really wish we had a gigabit network. 802.11g would be nearly unusable, and 802.11b would shut the company down.
Re:One Word (Score:2)
Re:One Word (Score:2)
Furthermore, wireless doesn't work well in practice for VoIP - especially if you want to use any encryption.
2 more words (Score:2)
Re:One Word (Score:2)
damn... (Score:2)
2 of us have just recently finished the 140 port setup in our new offices...
Re:damn... (Score:3, Funny)
Applies to cabling companies only (?) (Score:3, Informative)
Plenum (Score:5, Informative)
Also take a look at the cable faq [connectworld.net] and you will notice that it is very obvious that one really must be careful in installing the right type of cable w/ the appropriate firestops between floors (etc).
Actually... (Score:5, Informative)
From the FAQ:
Re:Actually... (Score:2)
Things like carpet, furniture, electronics - just about the entire contents of the normal home or office.
Re:Actually... (Score:2)
Re:Actually... (Score:2)
Re:Plenum (Score:2)
You can not use regular cat* cable when wiring up an office and/or house but must use plenum rated cable.
I don't think this is right... why then would they even sell non-plenum solid-core cable if it's not legal to install it anywhere? (Or do you just mean AU?)
I've installed plenty of cat5 before and to my knowledge the only place you have to use plenum cable (which sells for like 5x the price of normal cable) is where you run the cable through air circulation ducts or spaces. Most of the time, this mea
Re:Plenum (Score:2)
Like getting Slashdotted?
Re:Plenum (Score:2)
Re:Plenum (Score:4, Informative)
No you don't. You need to use plenum cable when you run cable through a plenum. That's why they call it plenum cable. If you don't know what the word plenum means, maybe you should look up plenum somewhere.
Quality work? (Score:5, Funny)
Re:Quality work? (Score:2)
My question is... (Score:2)
In a word, badly. In another word, Fsked.
I've done all my phone and network cable, about 1200 feet, myself and generally wouldn't trust someone else to do it. Sorry.
Get registered. (Score:2)
10 years, 40 hours a week (Score:2)
Well that is the answer if you want to do your own plumbing in Minnesota and live in a "community of over 2000 people". (I looked this up a few years ago) Apparently it takes that long to figure out that unpressurized water runs downhill, hot water pipes cannot be connected to cold pipes, and other such things that really are trivial.
Mind even after all this there are still inspectors to make sure the professionals are doing a good job. In my experience with professional plumbers the inspectors are requ
But what if they are right? (Score:4, Insightful)
Sure, plugging in cables is NOT HARD but yes, there are other things to worry about - fire shielding, run through an area people will not want to nail or drill into, and probably more that we don't know about. Stuff that once is mentioned, makes perfect sense but wouldn't be thought up unless someone mentioned it.
Hey, in California, I can see why you would need to be licensed to install PVC pipes. These earthquake things don't happen all the time but when they do, you'll want good bracing and give in your plumbing.
And then again, other parts of CA, do tend to get washed out with mudslides or decide to catch on fire on a semi yearly basis.
All I'm saying is that there's proooobably more behind the scenes that we're dismissing because we don't know about it.
Re:10 years, 40 hours a week (Score:2)
All an electrician needs to know to get a union card
1. 110 will shock you
2. 220 will kill you
3. 4:30 is quitting time
4. The boss is a sonnofabitch
The only thing a plumber needs to know:
1. Shit don't run uphill
Asked someone once about the price... (Score:3, Insightful)
I went and bought some wall mounts, screws, sockets etc, stole some cable from an industrial site(they were junking it and the guy on guard just let me take it before anyone asks) then sent my younger, and thinner, brother up into the roof to drag cables to the random holes I'd drilled into the ceiling inside the cupboards around the house, I had some problems with setting the wall ports(didn't know how to set the coloured wires right) and gave up on the project.
I left it for about five months, went back and using a newly acquired cable tester I set-up the sockets correctly, installed the hub and had a fully working LAN in about two hours.
Overall cost to me was about $70 and $20 for the cable tester which I gave to a friend as a Christmas present.
It took about six months from getting the cable to finishing the network but I believe I could have finished it in lest than a day if I'd given a damn about getting it done.
Essentially the asking cost was a rip off.
Another guy I know has a house they spent a summer networking, drilling through solid brick, hanging through air-con ducts and other random adventures until the ten of them and four other rooms were fully networked, their kitchen cupboard is four switches, two webservers/fileservers and some wheatbix no-one want to eat. It cost them a lot of spare time but other than a few drill bits, wall sockets and the cable their costs were non-existant, a cabler would have probably done it faster, but would have charged them at least $2000 for the work as well as a few hundred for the part.
I know about five other people that have networked their houses on almost no budget. Wires stapled to walls, running over rooftops and around the outside of buildings through walls and up attics.
Its a hobby and nothing anymore difficult or dangerous than putting up a painting and that you need some kind of certification for it is insane.
Re:Asked someone once about the price... (Score:2)
Re:Asked someone once about the price... (Score:2)
Er, you were able to get the cable for free, which is a substantial cost of the project. You also were able to get the labor for free via your own actions and that of your brother, which is a substantial cost of the project.
So no, $700 for that wasn't a rip-off; that takes into account (a) insurance, (b) warranty and (c) the guy makes his living doing this.
Same with your friend; he drilled through brick, hung air-con ducts, etc. -- that's a LOT of labor, and
I don't freakin' believe it. (Score:1)
We had the same problem here, but th
What about gas? (Score:2)
Makes sense to me.
Wireless (Score:2)
Lets see them audit that.
Cost & LV licensing (Score:3, Informative)
Licensing is a different issue. LAN cabling is considered low-voltage electric wiring and various governments sometimes like to control it. Sometimes for the permit & licence income, sometimes to support guilds, occasionally even for public protection (EMI & plenum smoke hazard). I believe *.de requires licencing.
It goes like this : (Score:3, Informative)
What to do?
Austel, the telecommunications authority, decided to implement a licensing scheme. Basically , if any part of your network interfaces with the phone lines coming from the street, well, you need to be an austel-licensed cabler to do anything with it. Becoming an austel licensed cabler is not hard, any monkey can do go through the motions.
Perhaps you should investigate asterisk (as some people have mentioned previously). Get all your lines terminated at a patch panel, put a nice server in the cupboard and ethernet from there on out to IP phones and the like. It might come out at the same price at the end, but you'll end up with a much more flexible system. You'll also have the advantage of getting on the IP telecom bandwagon and probably save a heap'o'cash in the long run on your phone bills.
Re:It goes like this : (Score:2)
This Old House (Score:4, Funny)
It's too expensive to be a general handyman for anything anymore.
Hmmmm ... not quite (Score:4, Informative)
The requirement actually is "thou shal not connect anything to the PSTN" which is not austel approved and/or installed by a licenced installer. You can do anything you want with your LAN, you can do anything you want with your telephone cabling on your companies side of the PABX
But, get your cabeling done by pros unless you know what you are doing. Ask yourself these quick questions:
Do I know when to use single core cable rather than 3 strand (and can I tell the difference between the RJ connectors for them)?
What is the maximim distance for an ethernet cable run?
Do I understand how to terminate cables and their wiring patterns?
Do I know how to test a wiring run?
If you didn't answer an emphatic yes to all those q's get the pros in. If you want to play at cabel monkey do it at home.
J
Re:Hmmmm ... not quite (Score:2)
Not so sure about testing, I'd just use a cable tester, so I doubt that's right.
Not that I'm qualified or anything
Nonsense (Score:2)
Granted, we have licensed individuals to do all our AC work, such as running power to the racks in the data center, and more often than not they pull ethernet and fiber for us, because it's part of their trade, and keeps them busy. (Our in-house elecs are really nice guys).
When it comes down to the
Home Wiring (Score:2, Interesting)
Another advangate of pro cablers (Score:4, Interesting)
My experience with the ACA... (Score:2)
We knew all the laws regarding separating from power, depth of trenches, what sort of cable and conduits etc. to use, so we did it. One of us had an open cabling registration, and five of the other six were in the middle of our cabling course, so legally we were covered there.
It worked great, I put up pictures on popular aussie geek site Whirlpool [whirlpool.net.au] and thought n
No issues in Canada (Score:2)
I remember doing the odd cable in a place I worked at. We just used plenum cable in the suspended ceiling in case it was used as a return for the ventilation.
As far as I know, you don't need a permit either way.
In government places, however, you don't touch the wires in the walls. It's a union thing...
Read Between the Lines... (Score:2)
the job.
Cabling which is installed incorrectly can result in your phones, faxes, Internet or alarm systems not working properly. Faulty cabling can also increase the risk of safety hazards such as electrocution.
It's like the building regulators saying your electrical wiring should be done by a professional. This is a "cover". Basically, if DIY and something goes wrong, the insurance compan
Re:That Sucks. (Score:2)